motherhood

Telling the Truth about Motherhood

The other evening, as I lay in my seven year-old’s bed waiting for sleep – hers, though my own comatose mini-nap usually comes first – an unexpected thing happened.

No, it wasn’t my questioning whether I should still be or have ever even started lying with her before bed without: a. spoiling her, b. impeding her sleep progress, c. prolonging this nighttime ritual until we’re both old and gray. That’s been a constant since she first balked at sleep as an infant.

As they usually do, an important revelation snuck out in those twilight murmurs.

“When I grow up, I don’t want to have children.”

My heart instantly hurt for so many reasons.

Sadness for her, that she wouldn’t experience the wonder that is mothering. The fierce, warming, all-enveloping love that it is to raise a little human into a big one.

Regret for me, that I somehow portrayed motherhood to my children in a poor light. That I did them a disservice by not loving it enough or not showing them enough love.

But even as I type that, I can’t believe that I don’t show my children enough love. Surely, they know they are loved. Does my fault lie in my sometimes less-than-joyful servitude?

As beautiful a sentiment Mother Teresa of Calcutta shares about washing the dish because you love the person who will use it next, that doesn’t make me more likely to wash dishes or to do so without complaining. Perhaps you’ve seen the list of things your mother never told you.

While many of these ten things are true on some level, I cannot subscribe to this level of subterfuge. Sacrifice and selflessness certainly have their place in parenting, but to sacrifice to the extermination of self is something for which I cannot get on board. Perhaps that means I am not destined for sainthood, but I also believe God created each of us as a special, sacred self to be celebrated – not obliterated.

I also feel it is disingenuous to serve with a smile when anger and resentment broil below. Why can’t we be authentic with our partners and children about how hard this path is? How we serve with love, but also appreciate being appreciated and, even more, equal distribution and support.

By speaking truth about my struggles in motherhood, I hope my daughters will see the inequalities in expectation and systems of modern motherhood. I also hope they will realize the hard-earned worth of fighting for a connected, loved, valued family.

Because while I stand as a symbol of the greater mantle of motherhood for my children, I am also human.

I hope the toil I am totally transparent about will not dissuade my daughters from becoming mothers themselves, but make them realize there is no perfect ideal – except perhaps love.

I also hope that my seven year-old’s proclamation didn’t stem from Cookie World C’s unnecessarily medicalized version of a plastic horse giving birth she viewed earlier that day.

In any event, I have some work to do, but tomorrow’s another day . . .

Standard

3 thoughts on “Telling the Truth about Motherhood

  1. “Perhaps that means I am not destined for sainthood, but I also believe God created each of us as a special, sacred self to be celebrated – not obliterated.”

    Amen!! He uses every inch of us, and we’re not to make idols of our children. Love them and sacrifice, absolutely. But lose ourselves in the process? No way!

    And for me, it helps reading Scripture and realizing how many people God used who did some pretty messed up things (Noah and his drunkenness; Samson and his, well, being Samson; David who essentially murdered and committed infidelity; Mary Magdalene and her seven demons…).

    We can never get in our own way when we follow God. He won’t allow it, and man, does that help this process called life!

    Love this post, Jennifer!

    Liked by 2 people

    • Jennifer Butler Basile's avatar Jennifer Butler Basile says:

      Following Him is the key. I always get in my own way- because I’m in my own head.

      Thank you for your perspective. And making me laugh with your description of Samson 😅

      Liked by 1 person

      • Lol! And you and me both! I’ve realized over the years, God never changes, but I constantly do and that’s half the problem. But He didn’t give up on the Israelites (who repeatedly gave up on Him), and He won’t give up on us either. Keep going, Jennifer! I really enjoy your writing and your heart. 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Ericka Clay Cancel reply